Three quotations are only useful if they price the same thing. A chauffeur service quotation for a government visit can be compared when the request states the days, the hours, the stops and the vehicles so exactly that each supplier is answering one question. A vague request produces three prices for three different services, and the lowest of them is usually the one that left the most out.
This guide is written for the supply chain officer who has to obtain the quotes and for the visit coordinator who has to live with the result. It does not replace your institution's supply chain policy. That policy decides how many quotations you need, in what form and from whom. What follows is about the content of the request.
Start from the programme
Take a three-day visit for seven officials. A request that says "transport for seven people for three days in Cape Town" can be answered with a sedan and a minibus, with three days of ten hours or three days of four, with fuel in or out. None of the answers is wrong, and none can be compared.
Write the programme into the request. For this visit it might read as follows.
| Day | Start and end | Programme | Approximate distance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 09:00 to 17:30 | Airport arrival, two meetings in the city centre, hotel | 40 km |
| 2 | 07:30 to 17:00 | Hotel, Stellenbosch, Paarl, hotel | 140 km |
| 3 | 08:00 to 16:30 | Hotel, Atlantis, lunch, airport departure | 110 km |
Day two is the heaviest day, and a supplier needs it in detail to price it.
| Time | Movement |
|---|---|
| 07:30 | Collect seven officials at the hotel in the city centre |
| 08:30 | Arrive in Stellenbosch, about 50 km |
| 08:45 to 11:00 | Meeting |
| 11:15 | Depart for Paarl, about 30 km |
| 11:50 to 15:30 | Lunch and a second meeting in Paarl |
| 15:45 | Depart for Cape Town, about 60 km |
| 17:00 | Hotel |
A supplier reading those two tables knows it is being asked for three consecutive days of eight and a half to nine and a half hours, with a longest day of about 140 km. That is a specification.
What the request should state
Put each of these in the request for quotation, as a numbered list, and ask suppliers to answer under the same numbers.
- Dates, start time and end time for each day. With the pick-up and drop-off address for the first and last movement.
- Number of passengers and pieces of luggage. Seven people with seven suitcases on day one is a different vehicle question from seven people with notebooks on day two.
- Vehicle requirement. The number of passenger seats required, the model year or age limit you will accept, and whether all seven must travel in one vehicle.
- Hours and kilometres included per day. Ask each supplier to state its own allowance, and the rate for each extra hour and each extra kilometre.
- What the rate includes. Driver, fuel, tolls and parking, each listed separately as included or excluded.
- Driver continuity. Whether the same driver will work all three days.
- Cancellation terms. Per day, with the notice periods.
- Payment terms. How and when your institution pays, stated by you, so each supplier accepts or declines in writing.
- Documents. The operating licence, the drivers' professional driving permits and proof of passenger insurance, to be shown with the quote.
- Validity of the quotation. In days.
Item 4 does the most work. A day rate with eight hours included and a day rate with ten are different products, and the gap only shows when day two ends at 17:00.
Comparing three written quotes
Lay the three replies out in one table before looking at the totals.
| Line | What to check |
|---|---|
| Seats | Do seven people and their bags fit in the vehicle quoted, or has one supplier assumed two vehicles |
| Hours per day | Does the allowance cover your longest day |
| Kilometres per day | Does it cover 140 km, and what does each further kilometre cost |
| Overtime | A rate per hour, stated in writing |
| Inclusions | Fuel, tolls and parking, line by line |
| Driver | One driver for three days, or whoever is on shift |
| Cancellation | What is retained if day three falls away with a day's notice |
| Documents | Shown, promised or not mentioned |
Then price the visit that will probably happen as well as the one on paper. Official programmes overrun. Add one hour of overtime to day two on each quote and compare the totals again. The order often changes. A quote that is lowest at eight hours a day and has a steep overtime rate is the dearest by Wednesday evening.
The cost that never appears on a quote is the meeting that starts without half the party. Seven officials who lose twenty minutes at each of four moves on day two have lost over nine working hours between them. No price difference between three suppliers of the same class is likely to outweigh that. This is the argument for specifying a vehicle that stays with the party all day, and one driver who is briefed once.
How West Landau answers these lines
Here is how the same list reads for West Landau. Check it against the others.
Seven passengers fit in one Hyundai Staria Luxury, which seats eight. With seven large suitcases on arrival and departure days a second vehicle is quoted, because a full Staria takes around four large suitcases plus hand luggage. A full day is 10 hours and 250 km. Overtime is billed per hour and extra distance per kilometre at the rates written on the quote. Driver, fuel and tolls are included, and venue parking is for the client's account unless itemised. Consecutive days run at a discounted daily rate with one dedicated driver for the whole booking.
Cancellation is free more than 48 hours before pick-up, 50% is retained inside 48 hours and 100% inside 24 hours or for a no-show, and on a multi-day booking those windows apply to each day. The operating licence, the drivers' professional driving permits and the passenger insurance are shown on request.
On payment, a booking is confirmed on full payment by EFT, and corporate and multi-day clients can be invoiced monthly on account by arrangement. If your institution has supplier requirements of its own, such as registration or specific documents, list them in the request. The concierge will answer each one in writing, and you should rely on that answer and not on anything in this article.
When a day rate is the wrong thing to ask for
If the visit is one arrival, one hotel and one departure, with the meetings in the hotel, ask for two airport transfers. A request for three day rates would buy a vehicle that stands in a parking area.
If the party is larger than 36, it is beyond the West Landau fleet of five vehicles, and the request should go to coach operators.
If only one day of the three has several stops, ask for that day as a full day and price the other two as transfers. One full-day booking or six separate transfers sets the two side by side.
Common questions
Should the request name a vehicle model?
Specify the outcome you need: the seats, the luggage capacity and the age of the vehicle. Naming a single model can exclude suppliers with an equivalent vehicle, and your policy may have a view on that.
Is the cheapest quotation the one to accept?
That is a matter for your policy and your evaluation criteria. What this guide can say is that a price is only comparable when the hours, kilometres and inclusions behind it are the same.
Can the programme change after the order is placed?
Programmes do change. Ask each supplier how a changed start time, an added stop or a cancelled day is handled, and get the reply in writing with the quote.
What should the supplier send before the visit?
At West Landau the client receives the driver's name, photo and direct number the evening before. Ask every supplier what it sends and when.
Send the concierge your request with the two tables, the passenger and luggage count and your institution's payment and document requirements. A written quote with a booking reference comes back within the hour during business hours. Rates are per vehicle and the fleet is on the corporate chauffeur page. For the visit itself, transport for visiting government officials works through two days in detail, and the delegation run sheet gives a programme table to copy.